ACGL vs AFL Stock Comparison
Scores Breakdown
| Metric | ACGL | AFL |
|---|---|---|
| 📈 Growth | 14/30 | 6/30 |
| 💰 Profitability | 16/20 | 10/20 |
| 🏦 Financial Health | 19/20 | 18/20 |
| 💵 Valuation | 12/20 | 14/20 |
| ⚠️ Risk (lower is better) | 3/10 | 6/10 |
| Overall Score | 68/100 | 52/100 |
Side-by-Side Summaries
| ACGL Analysis | AFL Analysis |
|---|---|
📈 Growth & Financial TrajectoryAcross the 8 most recent quarters (Q1 2026 through Q2 2024), ARCH Capital's revenues edged from about $4.521B to $4.229B, a decline of roughly 6-7%. Net income moved from about $1.047B to $0.988B, a modest downshift. The trajectory shows quarterly fluctuations but an overall stable earnings base, with operating income around $1.1B+ in most periods. 💰 Margins & Cash FlowMargins hovered in the mid-20% range (roughly 21–26%), and operating margins were similar, signaling disciplined costs and underwriting leverage. Cash flow: operating cash flow was robust in most quarters (e.g., Q1 2026 continuing ops of $1.189B; Q4 2025 around $1.404B), while investing and financing activities were frequently negative, reflecting asset deployment and capital returns. In Q1 2026, net cash flow was -$0.286B due to financing outflows. 🛡️ Balance Sheet & LiquidityAssets around $81.4B in Q1 2026, with current liabilities around $57.3B; current ratio ~1.4x. Equity near $24.2B and noncurrent liabilities essentially zero, implying strong liquidity and flexibility. ⚠️ Key Drivers & Risks
|
📈 Growth & Financial TrajectoryThe eight quarterly results show a mixed growth path. Start: revenues of $5.138B in 2024 Q2 and end: $4.346B in 2026 Q1, a decline of about 15%. Net income moved from $1.755B in 2024 Q2 to $1.019B in 2026 Q1, down roughly 42%. Notable quarter-to-quarter swings include a robust Q4 2024 and steady early-2025 quarters, but the overall trend is inconsistent, with revenue occasionally bouncing on seasonal/one-offs while earnings remain volatile. Operating income remained strong in several periods (around $3.0–$3.4B on mid-single to low-double-digit revenue), suggesting earnings power when volume picks up, but not a clear, sustained growth trajectory. 💰 Margins & Cash FlowMargins vary meaningfully by quarter; reported operating income margins range widely, reflecting unusual items and mix. Net cash from operating activities was solid in several quarters (e.g., $589M in 2025 Q1 and $968M in 2026 Q1) but softer in others (e.g., $315M in 2025 Q4). Investing and financing activities can create negative free cash flow in some periods, yielding an uneven cash flow signal despite positive operating cash in many quarters. 🛡️ Balance Sheet & LiquidityAssets typically sit around $116–$122B, with Liabilities in the $86–$93B range and Equity near $26–$30B, indicating reasonable leverage and strong liquidity. The structure supports resilience across varying earnings seasons, though reported items occasionally show anomalies in current liabilities. ⚠️ Key Drivers & Risks
|